Episode 12: Half-Hanged

History is full of people who took things too far. Humans are gifted at turning on one another, a skill we’ve honed over the millennia. But when a small town in colonial Massachusetts needed a scapegoat for a dying hero, they discovered a target who refused to go down without a fight.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 11: Black Stockings

Humans have a history of making up stories to explain the unexplainable. Sometimes we use those stories to teach our children a moral lesson, or entertain our friends. Sometimes, though, those stories get taken seriously, and the results have been unspeakable.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 9: A Devil on the Roof

Few stories have the endurance to last centuries. Fewer still have a proven track record of documented, authoritative eye witness accounts to back them up. Among those rare myths, one stands above most. For nearly 300 years, something has haunted an area of the country that is known for rare and unusual wildlife. So many people have seen it, in fact, that it’s almost impossible to deny its existence.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 8: The Castle

When the authorities entered a building in Chicago’s south side in 1895, they weren’t prepared for what they found. Above and below the neighborhood pharmacy was a seemingly never-ending maze of doors and rooms. What those hallways and staircases led to, however, was beyond disturbing.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 7: In the Woods

Stepping into the woods is like stepping through a doorway to another world. A world that hides dark secrets from prying eyes, and holds unknown dangers for unprepared travelers. But some woods are more sinister than others, and Massachusetts just might play host to the worst of them all.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 6: Echoes

Settings are often just as important to a story as the tale itself. The Shining had the Overlook. The Legend of Hell House had the Belasco. We fear cabins in the woods and even our own basements. But the mother of all horror settings is the asylum, with a dark pedigree unlike any other.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 5: Under Construction

Humans have always loved to build things, but we occasionally have to make adjustments to our plans. City ordinances, building codes, and property disputes all get in the way. Sometimes, though, the reason we change our plans is much more interesting than that.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 4: Dinner at the Afterglow

Deep in the forest at the northern tip of a small island near Vancouver Island, there is a stone monument standing amidst the trees. How that structure came to be, and what it meant to those who built it, are both interesting stories. But it's the unofficial reports — the sightings and experiences of those who visit it — that truly deserve to be told.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 3: The Beast Within

In 1582, the German town of Bedburg was ravaged by a violent and mysterious creature. After untold bloodshed, the townsfolk took up arms and hunted the monster down. What they found was something out of our deepest nightmares, and entirely too close to home.

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 2: The Bloody Pit

Over 200 lives were lost during the construction of the Hoosac Tunnel in western Massachusetts. According to countless eye-witnesses across nearly 150 years, many of those deaths left indelible marks. What truly awaits visitors in the darkness of that tunnel? Is it simple echoes of a violent past, or the thing that haunts the deepest fears of every human being?

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed

Episode 1: They Made a Tonic

On the morning of March 17, 1892, a group of townsfolk in rural Rhode Island dug up the graves of three local women. What they did to their bodies was something that we might find shocking, yet it was normal and expected for most of them. What was it in their past that guided their actions? Were they merely a product of their ancestors, or innocent participants in a regional panic?

Researched, written, and produced by Aaron Mahnke.



Subscribe for Free:  Apple Podcasts   iHeartRadio   Spotify  RSS Feed